Links Of Interest
Journal Authors
Subscribe Reviewers
Shopping Cart Continuing Education
 
 

OTHER MANUSCRIPT

REVIEW SUBMISSION PAGE
E-mail: editor@jopdent.org

Directions: This page will allow you to submit an OTHER MANUSCRIPT review. Please complete all the information below, then click "Review your Comments". You will have the opportunity to review your comments prior to e-mailing your comments to the editor. When you e-mail your review to the editor, a copy will be e-mailed to you, at the address you provide below.

Reviewer's name:
Reviewer's e-mail:
Manuscript Title:
Manuscript Number:

After reading the manuscript, please complete these questions and PROVIDE DETAILED SUPPORTING COMMENTS.

  1. Paper falls within the scope of Operative Dentistry:
    Yes  No
  2. There is a clear and concise presentation for the purpose of this manuscript:
    Yes  No
  3. The manuscript is:
    • logically presented:
      		•  Yes  No
    • clearly described:
      		•  Yes  No
    • properly sequenced:
      		•  Yes  No
  4. Includes all necessary parameters for the area reviewed:
    Yes  No
  5. Problems and solutions are totally and clearly described and discussed:
    Yes  No
  6. The manuscript provides information which will enhance dental practice:
    Yes  No
  7. The figures and tables:
    are adequate
    should be revised
    should be eliminated
    are not present but would help
    are not present and are not needed
  8. References
    are adequate
    are excessive
    are inadequate/inaccurate
    contain errors
    Are not applicable
  9. Contribution to the knowledge base is:
    major
    medium
    minor
    none
  10. The article should be:
    accepted for publication
    conditionally accepted for publication
    reconsidered after major revisions are completed
    rejected
  11. Reviewer's Comments:
  12. Confidential Comments for the Editor ONLY: